Torah and Tech· Note 07
Week Seven
By Benji Tusk
The Search for Alternative Sources - Mammals:
-
Introduction:
- Explores cultured meat production from mammalian sources, particularly focusing on beef and veal.
- Examines two primary methods: embryonic extraction and placental cell harvesting.
-
Embryonic Extraction:
- Describes the extraction process of muscle tissue cells, also known as satellite cells, from embryos.
- Differentiates between embryonic extraction and in vitro fertilization methods for obtaining stem cells.
- Discusses the halachic implications of considering embryonic stem cells as “mere secretions” based on Talmudic sources.
-
Talmudic Insights:
- Analyzes Talmudic passages regarding the chalei de’yachmurta, initially mistaken for eggs but later identified as dried semen.
- Explores interpretations by Rashi and Rabbeinu Gershom regarding the nature of chalei de’yachmurta and their permissibility.
-
Halachic Authorities’ Perspectives:
- Examines the rulings of Rambam, Ramban, and Rashba regarding the permissibility of consuming donkey placenta.
- Considers the applicability of these rulings to embryonic extraction for cultured meat production.
-
Contemporary Perspectives:
- Considers the comparison between embryonic stem cells and chalei de’yachmurta in contemporary discussions.
- Rabbi Stav’s viewpoint suggests that cultured meat is akin to “mere water” and not connected to the mother, resembling secretions.
- Rabbi Weiss expresses reluctance towards innovative methods and prefers harvesting stem cells from properly slaughtered animals.
-
Critique and Discussion:
- Critically evaluates Rabbi Weiss’s argument regarding the biological difference between male sperm cells and female egg cells.
- Discusses the likelihood of the Sages considering such biological differences in their halachic rulings.
The Placenta:
-
Introduction:
- Questions whether the permissibility of consuming a donkey’s placenta extends to all placentas or if it’s a unique case.
- Introduces a new Israeli startup exploring cultured meat production from bovine placental stem cells.
-
Talmudic Insights:
- Examines Talmudic passages regarding the permissibility of consuming a partially expelled placenta from a slaughtered animal.
- Considers Rashi’s interpretation that emphasizes the necessity of proper slaughter for permissibility.
-
Halachic Authorities’ Perspectives:
- Analyzes Rambam’s ruling that a partially expelled placenta is permitted if connected to the fetus, contrasting Raavad’s more lenient stance.
- Discusses the rabbinic prohibition status according to most Acharonim and Rabbi Weitman’s argument favoring the harvesting of stem cells from completely expelled placentas.
-
Resolution of Contradictions:
- Explains the apparent contradiction between Raavad’s leniency and Rambam’s stringency regarding the permissibility of placentas.
- Considers Rabbi Weitman’s perspective on the varying permissibility of placentas based on their expulsion from the mother’s body.
-
Contemporary Perspectives:
- Explores Rabbi Weitman’s inclination towards permitting the use of stem cells harvested from prohibited sources, aligning with Rav Ryzman’s opinion.
- Considers whether Rabbi Weitman’s approach could persuade those who reject the “mere water” interpretation to accept cultured meat derived from placental stem cells.
An Animal Born to a Slaughtered Animal:
-
Ben Peku’a Law:
- Discusses the Talmudic law of ben peku’a, where a living calf or lamb found inside its mother after slaughter is considered kosher without requiring further slaughter.
- Notes the exception mentioned by Rashi that standing on its hooves necessitates ritual slaughter due to concerns of improper appearances.
-
Rabbi Meir Rabi’s Perspective:
- Rabbi Meir Rabi proposed raising flocks of ben peku’a animals to mitigate issues of tereifa animals and suggested their meat might not be considered meat by Torah law.
- His proposal faced rejection from other poskim, citing concerns about improper appearances even with separate flocks.
-
Possibility of Utilizing Ben Peku’a Animals for Cultured Meat:
- Explores whether ben peku’a animals could serve as sources for stem cells considering the permission granted by the Shulchan Arukh regarding other tereifot.
- Considers the view of the Taz regarding the permissibility of consuming the blood of a ben peku’a and its implications for stem cell utilization.
-
Advantages and Challenges:
- Raises questions about the potential advantages and challenges of utilizing ben peku’a animals for stem cell extraction.
- Acknowledges the need for further analysis to determine the feasibility and implications of this approach for cultured meat production.
Is Slaughtering Required by the Torah?
-
Rav Schachter’s Perspective:
- Rav Schachter suggests that even if cultured meat is not fleischig mi-deOraita, it might still require slaughtering based on verses from Exodus and Deuteronomy.
- He cites a Machloket Rishonim regarding the status of an animal before slaughter, emphasizing the concept of chazakat issur.
-
Interpretations of Rishonim:
- Rashi and Tosafot interpret chazakat issur differently, with Rashi focusing on the lack of ritual slaughter and Tosafot considering it a presumption of non-slaughter.
- The discussion revolves around the definition of אבר מן החי and its implications for the requirement of slaughter.
-
Rabbi Weiss’s Rejection:
- Rabbi Weiss rejects Rav Schachter’s suggestion, arguing that the requirement for slaughter applies only to fully-formed animals or birds physically capable of being slaughtered.
-
Potential Exemption for Eggs:
- A chiddush by Rav Soloveitchik suggests that eggs grown from non-kosher birds might be exempt from the prohibition of meat from a non-slaughtered animal.
- This interpretation hinges on the concept that the prohibition of nevelah only applies after death, which doesn’t apply to eggs.